I'm not engaged in a trade or business, therefore no SE tax please

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • taxea
    replied
    I'm not engaged in a trade or business, therefore no SE tax please

    i would err on the side of the client and put it on a Sch C if the 1099 income exceeds the expenses by 400. I don't see how I could justify to the IRS that the issued 1099/s did not constitute business income if engaged in regularly and consistantly which still doesn't mean it has to be full time. taxea

    Leave a comment:


  • Lion
    replied
    Hobby

    If it's hobby income, no SE tax. Income less COGS on line 21, expenses on shedule A 2%. If business, SE tax. But, deductions on schedule C to reduce profits before putting on 1040, before computing SE tax, etc. Possible negative number on 1040 reducing other sources of income. And, NOLs possible to carry back &/or forward. I'm a little sleep-deprived so not sure if this is written right or clearly.

    Leave a comment:


  • JON
    replied
    Hobby income

    goes on line 21 with expenses to 1040 Sch A Misc Itemized deduction. Hobby income gross or net(assume income) is it subject to SE Tax??? If so is it gross(ca not be) or net, which usually brings income to 0. In this case with a 1099 it obviously makes it harder. I think hobby income is not SE-but have never seen it...

    Leave a comment:


  • veritas
    replied
    That is exactly what I am saying.

    Originally posted by joanmcq
    Sure they could. But it wouldn't be what was reported, now would it? Or are you saying filing a false 1096 to go with it? & signing & all?

    Lets see...forgery, filing false documents, what else?

    It is a potential area for abuse. Very unlikely it would be discovered and hard to pin on anyone.

    Leave a comment:


  • geekgirldany
    replied
    The client generated enough income from the site for them to send a 1099. Google Adsense and other affiliate type programs require your SS# before they pay. They will send a 1099-MISC if it does go over $600. It should have been reported on a Schedule C along with the expenses that go along with the website. Domain name renewal, hosting, etc.

    Leave a comment:


  • joanmcq
    replied
    Sure they could. But it wouldn't be what was reported, now would it? Or are you saying filing a false 1096 to go with it? & signing & all?

    Lets see...forgery, filing false documents, what else?

    Leave a comment:


  • veritas
    replied
    It occured to me the other day

    that someone who was less than scrupulous, could indeed correct their own (or anyone else's)1099s or W2s easliy.

    Leave a comment:


  • Kram BergGold
    replied
    1099 issue

    Your client received a 1099 with the income in box 7. You can contest the accuracy of the 1099 with the IRS. The IRS response of get it changed is not a final answer.
    You can appeal that examiner's decision.
    However, to me your client has a business. Let's say your client's hobby is chess playing. Some years he wins a little at tournaments. This is hobby income. Now he sets a web site having to do with chess and gets money from advertizers. To me this is a sepaate activity. The income has nothing to do with his earnings from playing chess. As this is not a one shot deal but a continuous activity he owes SE tax.

    Leave a comment:


  • travis bickle
    replied
    Agree with

    Originally posted by DaveO
    would be incidental to your business. Therefore I would include it on your "C" or "1120S". Now if you had a website about your chess hobby and it resulted in the odd bit of income from links I would say Line 21.

    The t/p in the original case messed up by not including income reported to the IRS. Had he put it on the original return it never would have been questioned.
    DaveO and taxea.

    If the incidental income is derived from/through your business website, it should be "miscellaneous business income", i.e., income -- not revenue -- derived as a by-product. Goes on L6 of Sch C.

    Leave a comment:


  • DaveO
    replied
    Erchess, your income

    would be incidental to your business. Therefore I would include it on your "C" or "1120S". Now if you had a website about your chess hobby and it resulted in the odd bit of income from links I would say Line 21.

    The t/p in the original case messed up by not including income reported to the IRS. Had he put it on the original return it never would have been questioned.

    Leave a comment:


  • LCP
    replied
    I guess the concensus is that any activity whatsoever that turns a profit is a "trade or business" and is subject to SE tax....... unless it is investing or renting of course.

    The only out I see in TheTaxBook is the "regular and continuous" concept (Batok TCM 12/28/92) at page 5-23.

    I know I've run into other opinions before but can't put my fingers on them. It may have been at a Gear UP seminar.

    Leave a comment:


  • taxea
    replied
    I'm not engaged in a trade or business, therefore no SE tax please

    I would say that this is a bi-product of the intent of your website and no it is not Ln21 it is Sch C other income. taxea

    Leave a comment:


  • erchess
    replied
    Really?

    I have a website for my tax business and I choose not to have links to commercial sites on it but what if I did put up links to sites that paid me for people who came to them from my site and spent money? Would I have to include that income in my business income or could I put it on 1040 L 21? Would it make any difference if the primary purpose of my website was related to an interest of mine that does not normally generate profit?

    If I were to put on my site a link to one and only one site that paid me for visitors I sent, it would be a link to a site where I play Chess. The site offers a free basic membership but there is a full membership that can be paid for in US Dollars, Euros, Great British Pounds or about any other currency in the world or can be paid for by recruiting other full members. If I had such a link I would very likely refer more people than necessary to get a free year of membership but months of membership can be collected indefinitely. I realize that my taxable income from doing this would be the cost of the number of months earned during the year and would not stop at the approximately $US25 cost of one year's membership. However I would be caught putting it down on my return as Hobby rather than Business income. Would I be wrong?
    Last edited by erchess; 10-07-2008, 05:09 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • taxea
    replied
    I'm not engaged in a trade or business, therefore no SE tax please

    Totally agree with DavidO. You may not think it is a business but selling for income is a business but it is how the IRS writes the rules not how you read them that counts. You do not have to engage in it "full-time". If it was a one-time thing then it goes on Sch D. However, this sounds more like at least part-time sales. taxea

    Leave a comment:


  • Snaggletooth
    replied
    SE tax

    I don't think there is a prayer in your situation for self-employment tax to be avoided.

    Had the taxpayer included this income in his original return as Line 21, he MIGHT have been under the radar if the amount was modest and not incidental to his occupation. But not including this income brought the entire situation to light, and IRS considers this to be business-related income resulting from his web creation.

    One of the worst things a taxpayer can do is to not claim income when there is a document notifying the IRS that the income exists.

    Leave a comment:

Working...