I'm not engaged in a trade or business, therefore no SE tax please

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • DaveO
    replied
    The IRS wants it both ways

    If an activity produces a profit it's a business. If it results in a loss it's a hobby.

    If they wish to maintain that it's a business then what are his costs of producing the income? Computers, internet connection, home office, domain registration, etc.

    I would say this income could be incidental to his hobby and reportable on Line 21 with expenses on "A". You don't say how much money is involved but that could be a factor as well. If he is receiving several thousand $ a year and expects to continue to, it becomes hard to argue it's not a business. If it's a few hundred $ per year and not expected to be more it's easier to argue that it's income incidental to the hobby.

    A few years back I had a client, a retired woman, who did some light delivery work for a friend who had a small business. She did it for only a few months until he could hire someone. He reported the income on a 1099 as non-employee comp. I reported it on line 21 when the IRS sent her a notice asking for the SE tax I replied that this was a one time event, she had not previously performed these services, had no intention of providing these services again, and therefore it didn't rise to the level of a trade or business. In this case the service agreed.

    Leave a comment:


  • LCP
    replied
    Sorry........ forget that I used the word "services". Just call it "income" ...... he performed no services.

    Leave a comment:


  • JohnH
    replied
    If "services" aren't subject to self-employment tax, then they shouldn't be subject to FICA/Medicare tax if someone is an employee. How is this argument going to fly?

    Leave a comment:


  • I'm not engaged in a trade or business, therefore no SE tax please

    Has anyone had success arguing that "services" should not be subject to SE tax?

    Taxpayer has a personal website related to his hobby. It gets enough traffic that he put a link on it that generated income every time someone clicked on it.

    Taxpayer didn't include the income at all unfortunately so the IRS assessed him. I filed an amended return but didn't treat it as SE income. I explained why (in general) but that didn't fly.

    IRS sent a notice that basically takes the position that it is SE income and "suggested" we need to get the payer to change the 1099 Non-employee Compensation they prepared. That isn't going to happen.
    Last edited by LCP; 10-07-2008, 08:52 AM.
Working...