planning idea- would it work?

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • TaxGuyBill
    replied
    I'm a bit fuzzy on what you are saying.

    Where does the Short Term Loss come into play? Unless something is being sold, isn't it just reducing basis?

    Leave a comment:


  • kathyc2
    replied
    Originally posted by Burke
    Interesting scenario. However, why wouldn't the custodian also charge another 3% upon "transferring" the money? It is not actually a transfer at all, but a sale or redemption and separate purchase in another type of vehicle as far as they are concerned.
    American Funds does not do this, although some other companies may. Once the money is with them you can move it without fees between funds or between non-qualified/Roth/IRA. I know this to be true because I've done it, but the non qualified to Roth idea just popped into by brain this morning.

    Leave a comment:


  • Burke
    replied
    Interesting scenario. However, why wouldn't the custodian also charge another 3% upon "transferring" the money? It is not actually a transfer at all, but a sale or redemption and separate purchase in another type of vehicle as far as they are concerned. Especially if he is buying the same fund. Because if he is not, I can't see the reasoning behind this course of action.
    Last edited by Burke; 11-22-2015, 11:03 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • kathyc2
    started a topic planning idea- would it work?

    planning idea- would it work?

    Say someone deals with American Funds or similar. They pay a up front load charge when they first invest new money, but then once the money is in no further transaction charges. Say they pay a 3% load charge and want to put 6,500 into a Roth.

    Instead of putting the money directly into Roth, they deposit the money to a non-qualified account. The 6,500 investment reduced by 3% or $195 for a net of 6,305. They then transfer the 6,305 to a different fund in their Roth.

    Net effect is they have increased Roth 6,305 same as if they made the contribution directly to Roth and paid the load there, but they would then also have a $195 ST loss to offset gains or ordinary income if no other capital gains.

    It seems like this would work, but maybe I'm missing something??
Working...