Self-employed health insurance and Medicare (again!)

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • FEDUKE404
    replied
    another surprise to me

    Originally posted by appelman
    Blue Cross isn't established under the name of any individual or business, either, but the individual policy is. Ditto for Medicare. But I guess you can't fight City Hall!
    ....and I certainly did not know that Medicare B is a "government entitlement program" - most folks I know currently pay a minimum of $1320/year for it!

    FE

    Leave a comment:


  • appelman
    replied
    Here we go again

    Blue Cross isn't established under the name of any individual or business, either, but the individual policy is. Ditto for Medicare. But I guess you can't fight City Hall!

    Leave a comment:


  • Bees Knees
    replied
    Originally posted by appelman
    An earlier IRS ruling did establish that the insurance could be taken out in your name rather than in the name of your business. That's what makes this development a little puzzling, if not downright disconcerting!
    I disagree.

    Section 162(l)(2)(A) still requires the plan providing the medical care coverage to be established under the business. That ruling did not change the code. The only thing that ruling said was health insurance that is in the name of the sole proprietor can be considered established under the business. Medicare Part B is not considered established under the name of any individual or business. It is a government entitlement program. Thus, it cannot meet the requirement imposed by the code that it has to be a plan established by a business to provide health insurance for a self-employed individual.

    Leave a comment:


  • appelman
    replied
    An earlier IRS ruling...

    An earlier IRS ruling did establish that the insurance could be taken out in your name rather than in the name of your business. That's what makes this development a little puzzling, if not downright disconcerting!

    Leave a comment:


  • FEDUKE404
    replied
    Not again ?!?

    On these boards this topic has previously been beaten to a pulp, shredded, spindled, mutilated, and a few other similar actions.

    While the phrase "established in the name of the business" has been a constant sticking point for many, the counter argument has always been what about a self-employed individual who IS the business? (Not to sound overly dense, but the item does go by the name "Self-Employed Health Insurance Deduction.")

    The classic example is for retiree Joe who starts his own consulting business (and even pays SE taxes!! ) and he continues to pay family medical coverage available to him through his former employer. (Assume neither spouse is an employee.) Does Joe have a valid deduction? (His former employer offers coverage to Joe but not to Joe's Consulting Services.)

    As for the "TIP" in the middle of page 18 of the 2009 Pub 535, when/how did the IRS start "considering" those insurance expenses non-deductible ??

    It appears that rule A has been replaced by statement of fact B.

    FE

    Leave a comment:


  • Jiggers
    replied
    Agree on non-deductible

    I was one that supported Claudia Hill, then read further into her information and I really believed that she was calling it a medical deduction and letting us take the heat if audited.

    I have since switched to making this strictly a medical deduction and not a self-employed health insurance deduction.

    I am glad that the IRS has finally said so. Don't know what took them so long.

    Leave a comment:


  • Bees Knees
    replied
    A position I took way back in 2005, despite so called experts like Claudia Hill making the claim you could.

    Primary Forum for posting questions regarding tax issues. Message Board participants can then respond to your questions. You can also respond to questions posted by others. Please use the Contact Us link above for customer support questions.


    Maybe IRS Pub writers read my argument and decided it made sense.

    Leave a comment:


  • Burke
    replied
    It is not something that was slipped in. Just qualified by stating it in the Pub. It has never been an expense which qualifies for the SE deduction. It says "the insurance plan must be established under your trade or business,....." and the MC tax and/or premium for Part B does not meet this requirement. It has nothing to do with a trade or business. If you want the definitive, detailed analysis of this, see BeesKnees reply dated 9/16/05 in old thread.
    Last edited by Burke; 10-18-2010, 01:01 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Self-employed health insurance and Medicare (again!)

    The IRS has quietly slipped into Pub. 535 language expressly stating that Medicare B does not qualify for the self-employed health insurance above-the-line deduction. I have not found any recent ruling or advice memo that might have precipitated this. The code and regs remain pretty silent on the issue, particularly once you accept that qualifying insurance can be taken out in the name of the owner rather than in the name of the business.

    I had gotten the recent impression that practitioner opinion was moving in the direction of taking this deduction. In fact, it seems hard to understand why Medicare B should be treated differently from any other electively purchased group insurance plan.

    But it also seems hard to argue when its spelled out in black and white. Does anyone think we might have any alternative other than to acquiesce? I have a client to whom this is worth a couple of thou an year in taxes.
Working...