W2 is wrong

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • FEDUKE404
    replied
    I don't recall ever being present at "a tax appointment" where a large portion of the time dealt with determining if numbers reported on a W2 were correct and/or then changing how I enter said data appearing on the W2.
    That's why the Good Lord came up with CORRECTED tax documents as an option to repair things.
    Regardless of any quoted due diligence issues that might be in play, I have serious doubts if such an egregious error would have been committed repeatedly, without any source corrections, by the Nissan corporate folks. A reasonable person could easily reach the conclusion. . .that the W2 is correct as issued.

    Leave a comment:


  • Beersheba
    replied
    Burke, thanks for your input. I thought the thread was mercifully closed but your comments are very appropriate, so I will post again.

    There is not a single post supporting what I have done, and maybe there shouldn't be. The outcry has ranged from virtual ignorance to lack of due diligence to total incompetence.

    I have concentrated on the unfairness of the Nissan W-2, rather than portray how I responded to the information I had at my disposal. I believe while at a tax appointment, all of us are confronted with a "preponderance of the evidence," to borrow a phrase from criminal law. We have to make decisions based on what we see and make reasonable judgments accordingly, without chasing down any remotely conceivable improprieties of the information presented to us.

    In the Nissan situation, the taxpayers' daughter, who has a PhD in Chemical Engineering (if that's worth anything), presented fair market rental value that she received from Nissan itself. Not only was this authentic information from Nissan, but also having some idea myself of what autos rent for, the FMV appeared to me to be reasonable. The amount monthly paid came from the taxpayer and was a known parameter, assuming again that the family was telling the truth. The difference was simply a matter of arithmetic subtraction.

    The W-2s were reduced accordingly to the benefit derived, consistent with what Nissan claims to be their policy (notwithstanding how their W-2s are calculated).

    I have to make the case for dealing with reasonable interpretation of information available at a tax appointment. This axiom does not always work in favor of the taxpayer, as obvious understatements of revenue or overstatement of expenses are met with the same criteria, and these are not compromised with wild stretches of imagination that I hear from the client.

    Burke, thank you for entering the fray.


    Last edited by Beersheba; 04-06-2022, 12:30 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Burke
    replied
    Late to the discussion, but I agree with the validity of the statements by other posters on this board. Given the additional information by OP, it appears this issue has been addressed with the Company before and not resolved. If the TP wants to take the Company to court over it, that is his right to do so. kathyc2 is right on when she says to obtain the contract the TP signed. But that is not the responsibility of the preparer. If the lease agreement substantiates the TP's position that they are reporting an incorrect amount, then at least the preparer has something to back up filing 4852 in lieu of the W-2. It appears, however, that the preparer is using other subjective substantiation for not using W-2.
    Last edited by Burke; 04-05-2022, 08:12 AM.

    Leave a comment:


  • ATSMAN
    replied
    Not sure how the Original Poster operates his/her business BUT I am sure if this came to litigation and the Liability Insurance carrier got wind that their insured changed amounts on a W2 that was not within the scope of work they would deny any claims.

    I agree completely with other posters who suggested proper due diligence before giving any opinion to a taxpayer. Stuff in the gray areas always comes to bite you when you least expect it. Better to check twice and write once!

    Leave a comment:


  • Rapid Robert
    replied
    "No reduction is afforded based on payments,"

    What surprises me (not really) is that no effort seems to have been put into identifying the exact detailed nature of the payments, and whether they would be deductible or additions to basis, as alluded to in post #6.

    Leave a comment:


  • kathyc2
    replied
    I am gobsmacked that a tax professional would take it upon themselves to use a different amount on a tax return than what shows on a W2 without doing their due diligence. I hope you explained to client any potential tax penalties of this action.

    Leave a comment:


  • Beersheba
    replied
    Kathy if you're going to continue to find things wrong with my posts, you will be presented with an abundance of material.

    Leave a comment:


  • kathyc2
    replied
    If you filed the 4852 last year, why was your first question asking what the form is?

    You filed a 1040 using the numbers you came up with on the 4852?

    You did the above without even getting a copy of the lease agreements?


    Leave a comment:


  • Beersheba
    replied
    Yes, I have run into this issue last year, and again the conventional wisdom from the most learned people seemed to think that the well-resourced Nissan with their Army of lawyers and CPAs were surely with more advanced than myself. I used Form 4952 last year, and no ugly letters from the IRS - of course they are way behind.

    If the customer receives repercussions from this, I believe it is a winner based upon math alone. The "gross" values are supplied by Nissan itself, and tie to the taxable amount on the W-2 - according to the clients' daughter. No reduction is afforded based on payments, and the 2012 document supplied by Judy on the other forum supports our treatment as well.

    Leave a comment:


  • FEDUKE404
    replied
    Deja vu ??
    https://www.atxcommunity.com/topic/2...n-tax-rip-off/

    Leave a comment:


  • kathyc2
    replied
    Originally posted by Beersheba
    Ah yes, the iggo-nert TN tax preparer is called out (again), with jug of moonshine by his side. This time ostensibly pitted against a team of lawyers from a Fortune 500 company.
    Oh, don't get your panties in a wad.

    If you want to know how Nissan came up with the amount, get a copy of the contract from your client. More likely than not, the amounts used are shown in the contract.

    Leave a comment:


  • Beersheba
    replied
    Ah yes, the iggo-nert TN tax preparer is called out (again), with jug of moonshine by his side. This time ostensibly pitted against a team of lawyers from a Fortune 500 company.

    I would be interested to see if this has ever gone to court - maybe NYEA keeps up with this sort of stuff. This would most likely not be a tax court case with the IRS involved. It could be as Nissan being the defendant.

    I don't think it is a matter of tax law, or any law for that matter. It is a matter of simple math. If the FMV lease of a 2018 Rogue is $360 per month ($4320 annually), and the discounted rate is $320 per month, the benefit is $40 per month, or $480 per year. If this is the only vehicle involved, the W-2 should not be for $4320 but instead of $480. In my situation, the client is paying for 3 autos, with the discounted rate being offered as a former employee.

    Further, if you stop and think about it, given a sufficient tax bracket, if every discounted situation were taxed at the gross FMV rate, no one would accept the offer, as the tax cost would outweigh the benefit. That may have something to do with Kathy's point that the taxpayers are not being forced to accept these deals. If I rented three late model vehicles and had to pay tax on the gross value, I would turn it down even if I were in the 12% bracket.

    I don't know whether my client's W-2 is an isolated incident, or whether Nissan's error is more widespread. I will also admit to not being familiar with other such agreements, such as possibly Ford, GM, or Toyota, nor have a read the legal jargon in such agreement. It is a matter of simple math.

    Sorry guys, I'm not the most popular kid on the block - I've been dumped on before, here and elsewhere. I'm simply not going to back off a situation as blatantly unfair as this.

    Leave a comment:


  • FEDUKE404
    replied
    MY bet goes to it's a correct W2, along the lines of the points raised upthread by Rapid Robert.

    Leave a comment:


  • kathyc2
    replied
    No one if forcing him to use the discounted lease, are they? His choice if he want to use it and pay any associated taxes or not. I'm sure Nissan has a team of lawyers and accountants that oversee the program and contracts. Highly doubtful a tax preparer from TN knows more about it than they do, but.......

    Leave a comment:


  • Rapid Robert
    replied
    Do you know enough about the Nissan Vehicle Purchase Program (VPP) for employeess and other affliates to judge whether the W-2 is accurate or not? Are the payments being made in arrears? Do the payments include taxes and other fees?

    Leave a comment:

Working...