Appealing a Levy

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • taxea
    replied
    My understanding is that the IRS has a given amount of time to make a decision. Your client should not be delayed because the IRS is shorthanded. I think this is an administrative issue. Research and cite the law that says the issue is consided resolved (in TP's favor) if the IRS fails to respond in a timely fashion.

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzardbreath
    replied
    Note to All

    The impact of my message above was not intended to portray indifference to those who did make suggestions, indeed they are in many situations helpful. I do appreciate input, even though not directly germane to the question, that reflects on strategies possibly overlooked.

    Know that all of you are appreciated, and don't hesitate to be the kind of people that you are.

    Truth is NOT something wrought of convenience, nor is it just what someone wants to hear. Truth is not what leaves the least egg on your face.

    It is what it is.

    Leave a comment:


  • geekgirldany
    replied
    I only suggested the TAO because they have been so helpful with me regarding such situations and they have always been resolved quickly. I know you said they would not help this year but I worked with them just a few months ago with regards to a notice to levy. TAO took the case and was resolved in month. So, I know my answer was simple, did not go into details about doing an appeal. I thought going though TAO would be more helpful.

    Leave a comment:


  • Black Bart
    replied
    Another observation

    Just to get it out of the way; I did not know how to appeal a levy -- borrowing your phrase, I too had "Never done this before. Never had to." Now, thanks to NYEA, I do.

    Originally posted by buzzardbreath
    NYEA, thanks for your response.

    I will make a general statement about making a post on this forum. First, it's sometimes hard to get the respondents to simply answer the question - in fact, if you read the first few responses to this thread you will find this to be the case. Secondly, if you give out details that do not contribute to the issue at hand, this gives opportunity for respondents to go off on another tangent which may not significantly relate to the topic.

    Others have noted...preparer/taxpayer did not jump through...necessary hoops...and ...placed the situation in jeopardy...we did everything timely...did not drag the forum through the garden on the original post...

    Chronology is as follows: ... I guess I didn't realize all the above would be of any interest to anyone for purposes of answering an initial question. As far as I can tell, none of this altered the question, or the answer.
    Your points are well-taken and your frustration re straight answers is understandable. However , not everybody here is an EA/CPA/knowledgeable non-credentialed preparer (anybody with the price of a book can post). Posters frequently ask very basic questions, have no knowledge of tax fundamentals (yes, I'm sure some are thinking of me), don't want to do any "homework", or...simply need a quick answer. Problem is, we don't know who's who and therefore "asking for the details" is a necessary evil. There's no point in boarders beginning complex explanations (NYEA is a nationally-known tax expert) until you furnish the "hoop-jumping" details (we've got the time and accountants like them for breakfast). Otherwise nobody knows whether you've ever even heard of PPS/TA, etc. and the first few answers offered were much simpler (I think) than going through appeals. A case history demonstrates level of knowledge and is sometimes necessary to crafting good answers (your chronology recap shows you obviously know the ropes and maybe won't have to next time). As to going off on another tangent, well...as one who lives in a glass house, I can't address that problem.

    Mostly though, we want to help. While we may not know the exact answer, we'll tell you what we do know and think is the best way is to solve the problem.

    But anyway, stick around. You're among friends .

    Leave a comment:


  • S T
    replied
    Observation - [and I am guilty more times than not in explainng my post] While some of us might not know the answers on an original OP - sometimes it is important for the OP to give some type of fact pattern with items. It has been pointed out several times in past posts - so ---- sometimes more information is better than less -- don't be too discouraged, as there is some great info and feedback.

    Glad you are here and posting - welcome!

    Sandy

    Originally posted by buzzardbreath
    NYEA, thanks for your response.

    I will make a general statement about making a post on this forum. First, it's sometimes hard to get the respondents to simply answer the question - in fact, if you read the first few responses to this thread you will find this to be the case. Secondly, if you give out details that do not contribute to the issue at hand, this gives opportunity for respondents to go off on another tangent which may not significantly relate to the topic.

    Others have noted that the tandem of preparer/taxpayer did not jump through the necessary hoops from the outset, and therefore have placed the situation in jeopardy of levy. I believe we did everything timely, but did not drag the forum through the garden on the original post. Some of my posts are notoriously lengthy in their own right, and no need to elongate them further.

    Chronology is as follows:
    1. Taxpayer was notified by correspondence that a deficiency on April 2nd, to the horror of my client. Out of courtesy for the season, I asked to postpone response until after April 15th.
    2. April 29th - taxpayer agreed in part to a $3400 assessment, and paid $1400 promptly. We called the correspondence office, who agreed the remaining $2000 would be absolved if we could supply them with the information.
    3. May 3rd - I prepared a package for the taxpayer's signature, outlining the facts and presenting documentation which would resolve the $2000.
    4. July 1 - Notice of Intent to Levy and Right to Appeal issued to taxpayer for remaining $2000 plus penalty/interest.
    5. Sometime during July - Taxpayer gets letter acknowledging our May 3rd correspondence and announcing it would take another 60 days to arrive at a resolution. Power-of-attorney executed.
    6. July 23 - Collection office notified by phone that audit division had the resolution held up. They told us that wasn't their problem, i.e. WE would have to take the initiative to get the audit division to complete their work. 30-day extension was granted.
    7. July 24 - Notified audit division by phone, who acknowledged receipt of our May 3rd letter, and asked me to fax the details (again) to someone who would personally make sure a decision would be forthcoming. 26-page fax sent.
    8. Sept 9 - Collection office notified that a levy on social security payments would be imminent, inviting us again to call them, or to appeal. (No instructions given as to how to appeal).

    I guess I didn't realize all the above would be of any interest to anyone for purposes of answering an initial question. As far as I can tell, none of this altered the question, or the answer.
    Last edited by S T; 09-16-2013, 09:52 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzardbreath
    replied
    Details mostly redundant

    NYEA, thanks for your response.

    I will make a general statement about making a post on this forum. First, it's sometimes hard to get the respondents to simply answer the question - in fact, if you read the first few responses to this thread you will find this to be the case. Secondly, if you give out details that do not contribute to the issue at hand, this gives opportunity for respondents to go off on another tangent which may not significantly relate to the topic.

    Others have noted that the tandem of preparer/taxpayer did not jump through the necessary hoops from the outset, and therefore have placed the situation in jeopardy of levy. I believe we did everything timely, but did not drag the forum through the garden on the original post. Some of my posts are notoriously lengthy in their own right, and no need to elongate them further.

    Chronology is as follows:
    1. Taxpayer was notified by correspondence that a deficiency on April 2nd, to the horror of my client. Out of courtesy for the season, I asked to postpone response until after April 15th.
    2. April 29th - taxpayer agreed in part to a $3400 assessment, and paid $1400 promptly. We called the correspondence office, who agreed the remaining $2000 would be absolved if we could supply them with the information.
    3. May 3rd - I prepared a package for the taxpayer's signature, outlining the facts and presenting documentation which would resolve the $2000.
    4. July 1 - Notice of Intent to Levy and Right to Appeal issued to taxpayer for remaining $2000 plus penalty/interest.
    5. Sometime during July - Taxpayer gets letter acknowledging our May 3rd correspondence and announcing it would take another 60 days to arrive at a resolution. Power-of-attorney executed.
    6. July 23 - Collection office notified by phone that audit division had the resolution held up. They told us that wasn't their problem, i.e. WE would have to take the initiative to get the audit division to complete their work. 30-day extension was granted.
    7. July 24 - Notified audit division by phone, who acknowledged receipt of our May 3rd letter, and asked me to fax the details (again) to someone who would personally make sure a decision would be forthcoming. 26-page fax sent.
    8. Sept 9 - Collection office notified that a levy on social security payments would be imminent, inviting us again to call them, or to appeal. (No instructions given as to how to appeal).

    I guess I didn't realize all the above would be of any interest to anyone for purposes of answering an initial question. As far as I can tell, none of this altered the question, or the answer.

    Leave a comment:


  • DaveO
    replied
    A former IRS agent gave me the following tip; Whenever I'm responding to a CP2000 or CP504 I add the follwing sentance or similiar at the bottom of the letter.

    Should this information not be sufficient to adjust the taxpayers account as requested I request an immediate transfer to appeals for further review.

    I sometimes get a call from appeals but I always get some action.

    Leave a comment:


  • New York Enrolled Agent
    replied
    Originally posted by buzzardbreath
    The collection division is not willing to wait on the audit/correspondence office for a determination. Instead they reinforce further collection notices, and taxpayer really does not owe the money. But he has to wait on the audit/correspondence office to clean up the problem.

    Very unfair. Kind of situation that needs bringing to the attention of our congressman. In general, congress makes a lot of noise but will do very little to impede the machinery of the IRS. But I have known congressmen to make inquiries and get results sometimes.
    You have apparently not shared all the details of the taxpayer's situation in your posts.

    You say "The collection division is not willing to wait ...". It appears your taxpayer may have been dilatory.

    The only way collection activity can be currently in place is because an assessment has been made. Did the taxpayer self-assess? Or did the IRS make a subsequent assessment to a tax return? If that is the case, there was certainly an opportunity for the taxpayer to contest the proposed assessment. IRS assessments are made only after the issuance of a 90-day letter. Did you not react to that Notice? If the taxpayer didn't act, I fail to understand why this is unfair. Taxpayers have rights - shame on them if they didn't use them. Levy action is not something that occurs over night - you need to give details.

    Leave a comment:


  • Burke
    replied
    Originally posted by buzzardbreath
    We've contacted the correspondence division who say their issues are stacking up on their desks and they don't have the manpower to do anything except to mail out letters telling taxpayers they should "get a solution in 60-90 days".
    Which very well may be true with budget cuts and everything else going on. Contacting a congressman may bump a case up to the top, but they are the ones who control these purse strings and nothing is going to get better until that is resolved.

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzardbreath
    replied
    Thanks to All

    Thanks to all who have responded. It helps me determine a course of action.

    The collection division is not willing to wait on the audit/correspondence office for a determination. Instead they reinforce further collection notices, and taxpayer really does not owe the money. But he has to wait on the audit/correspondence office to clean up the problem.

    Audit/correspondence office has sent out two letters - stating they need 45 days to examine the facts, and yet another letter stating they need yet another 60 days. In the meantime, we have held off collection division as long as we could.

    Very unfair. Kind of situation that needs bringing to the attention of our congressman. In general, congress makes a lot of noise but will do very little to impede the machinery of the IRS. But I have known congressmen to make inquiries and get results sometimes.

    Leave a comment:


  • DaveinTexas
    replied
    Great follow up sir

    Originally posted by New York Enrolled Agent
    Dave

    I'm going to disagree a bit.

    First to Buzz - it's hard to tell exactly what your taxpayer received. It could be a CP504 notice of levy but from your post I'm going to assume that your taxpayer received a letter 1058 that gave notice of levy and right to a hearing in appeals. If so you have 30 days to request a collection due process (CDP) hearing. Dave gave you a link - complete Form 12153 and mail it off and you will get an Appeals conference.

    If you miss the 30 day deadline, you have up to one year from the date of the notice to request an equivalent hearing (EH).

    A timely request for a CDP results in a required stoppage of the levy action. A request for an EH does not require stoppage but both the regulations and the IRM say that generally levy action will stop.
    That's what I get for answering questions during this crazy week. Good information and thank you for being so thorough.

    Leave a comment:


  • New York Enrolled Agent
    replied
    Originally posted by DaveinTexas
    You have up to 1 year from the date of the Levy Notice to appeal the levy with a CDP Hearing request.
    Dave

    I'm going to disagree a bit.

    First to Buzz - it's hard to tell exactly what your taxpayer received. It could be a CP504 notice of levy but from your post I'm going to assume that your taxpayer received a letter 1058 that gave notice of levy and right to a hearing in appeals. If so you have 30 days to request a collection due process (CDP) hearing. Dave gave you a link - complete Form 12153 and mail it off and you will get an Appeals conference.

    If you miss the 30 day deadline, you have up to one year from the date of the notice to request an equivalent hearing (EH).

    A timely request for a CDP results in a required stoppage of the levy action. A request for an EH does not require stoppage but both the regulations and the IRM say that generally levy action will stop.

    Leave a comment:


  • DaveinTexas
    replied
    CDP Hearing

    Originally posted by buzzardbreath
    Thanks to all of you who have responded and proposed ideas OTHER than appealing a levy.

    Each of the ideas has been tried, and we have had 30-day extensions. I appreciate all these other suggestions - well-meaning as they may be, no one has answered the question.

    But I ask you again, does anyone know how to appeal a levy? The intent letter says we can appeal but not give us details as to how to do so.
    You have up to 1 year from the date of the Levy Notice to appeal the levy with a CDP Hearing request.

    See form 12153: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f12153.pdf

    Good luck, fill us in when you get some results!
    Last edited by DaveinTexas; 09-14-2013, 07:29 PM. Reason: Misspelling

    Leave a comment:


  • WhiteOleander
    replied
    Originally posted by buzzardbreath
    Thanks to all of you who have responded and proposed ideas OTHER than appealing a levy.

    Each of the ideas has been tried, and we have had 30-day extensions. I appreciate all these other suggestions - well-meaning as they may be, no one has answered the question.

    But I ask you again, does anyone know how to appeal a levy? The intent letter says we can appeal but not give us details as to how to do so.
    Try this
    http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f9423.pdf

    Leave a comment:


  • buzzardbreath
    replied
    How to Appeal a Levy

    Thanks to all of you who have responded and proposed ideas OTHER than appealing a levy.

    Each of the ideas has been tried, and we have had 30-day extensions. I appreciate all these other suggestions - well-meaning as they may be, no one has answered the question.

    But I ask you again, does anyone know how to appeal a levy? The intent letter says we can appeal but not give us details as to how to do so.

    Leave a comment:

Working...